UPDATE: My final review- Nikon D5200 vs Canon T4i(650D) Comparison

The T5i has been released. It performs identically in low light to the T4i. There are other slight differences between the T4i and T5i.   Watch my T5i (700D) vs D5200 video.

Buying the Nikon or Canon through my links supports this site and costs you nothing extra.

I have a video comparison of the physical difference/similarities and a video with sample 1080P video from both cameras showing autofocus ability(Canon wins) and a video/audio test Canon t4i vs Nikon D5200(Winner-Toss up?) and low light – high iso video samples from both cameras.  – Scroll down for embedded videos.

A few thoughts/comparisons:

  • Both cameras are capable of producing excellent images but the kit lens(18-55) for the Nikon is not great and that sensor shows it, high quality sensors need higher quality lenses.
  • Nikon image quality in lower light is noticeably better and overall image quality is better but it is very close.
  • Canon seems to be better at focusing and refocusing during video that coupled with a STM makes for smooth and fairly painless auto focus suitable for family and vacation videos.
  • Both cameras, with 18-55 kit lens, produce sound during focus that is picked up by the on board stereo mic while filming.  Canon does offer the silent 18-135 STM lens, Nikon does not have a comparably silent lens but the 18-55 on the Nikon is quiet, just not silent. UPDATE: With the T5i Canon now offers an 18-55 STM lens that is also silent.
  • The touchscreen and button layout of the Canon makes the camera more friendly to operate.  Worth repeating, the touchscreen is NICE!
  • The Nikon has a few more effect options under the effect dial
  • The Nikon offers a quiet shutter mode, two different burst speeds(low & high) and intervalometer and a few more features.
  • The Canon offers wireless external flash control.
  • The Canon gives someone with larger hands just a bit more space.
  • The Nikon has a few quirks
  • Nikon offers a $60 wireless dongle utility.

Complete Review of the T4i and Nikon D5200 is now available.

Have a question you want answered now or in the video review?  Leave it on my Facebook page or a comment below.

 


Nikon D5200 low light test. from Hans zijffers on Vimeo.

Video clips all shot with the Tamron 17-55 F2.8. ISO 1600 – 3200. Denoising was done on all shots to make it look as clean and crisp as possible.

* Keep in mind that the raw video footage out of the D5200 can be noisy at ISO 1600 and above, especially in dark areas with little light available. (although I shot at ISO 4000 and saw very little noise due to the fact that there was enough light coming from a street lantern) The footage you see in this video is not colour corrected, very basic, I only added some brightness to pull details out of dark areas (the dynamic range is absolutely stunning in this camera!), then denoised it and added some sharpness. The camera picture style was set to Neutral with zero contrast and very little sharpening.

Download the 720p file to see the best result.

Canon T4i vs Nikon D5200
Canon T4i vs Nikon D5200

Follow me on Instagram | Watch my latest Youtube Video | Subscribe to my YouTube Channel




 I love traveling with other photographers on #mckaylive trips. Kari, a trip participant, noticed this line of trees and shared her perspective with me. I had glanced at them but hadn't noticed how nicely they lined up when standing at a certain spot #teacherbecomesthestudent :) We had a great day leaving behind the cherry blossom crowds for a much quieter walk around #HarpersFerryWV. And a visit to #BolivarHeights a much fought over hilltop during the civil war and the site of the largest surrender of Union troops - over 12,000 men surrendered to Stonewall Jackson. *  Captured with the #Panasonic #GH4 and #1235mm lens
 "Such a blunder sometimes it makes me wonder why I even bring the thunder" * The Jefferson Memorial might be my favorite. Jefferson's quotes inside, the circular structure surrounded by the columns, the fact that it is perched on a more organic, curving body of water. There is much to love here! Inside I chose to go wide with the 12mm Laowa to capture that awesome dome and offer a different perspective. * Captured with the #Sony #A7RII and @venuslaowa #12mm f/2.8 lens
 Up early and rewarded with another fantastic sunrise. The colors were brief but beautiful. There were literally thousands of photographers lined up along the tidal basin. The reflections were beautiful but those can be captured anytime of the year, it was important to include some of the blossoms. *  Captured with the #Sony #A7RII and #Canon 24-70 lens


Want to be a better photographer? Become a Photorec.tv Member! $5/Month gets you access to my Lightroom video library the support group and more!

Support this site - Shop for anything through the links below and I earn a small percentage - it costs you nothing extra.

2 COMMENTS

  1. Thank you very much, Toby, for the excellent reviews and tutorials.

    There are two points that might be worth re-evaluating:

    1) It is possible that the slightly-soft photos produced by your D5200 are not due to the mediocrity of the kit-lens, but rather a slight vibration of the sensor, resulting from the impact produced by the mirror. It is worth checking, simply by comparing photos taken at Live-View mode with those taken while using the viewfinder — both at relatively low shutter speeds, such as 1/30-1/80. Maybe your specific unit is flawed in this respect? This link might be of some interest to you and to readers who consider buying the d5200:
    http://www.pocket-lint.com/news/49243/nikon-d5200-sharpness-issues-mirror-slap-autofocus-system-d7000-error

    2) Strangely, and in contrast to your low-light video test, the following video shows that the T4i’s footage in low-light is much cleaner than that produced by the D5200:
    http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QpG2NmOUYL8
    However, this comparison was shot at ISO 1600 (while yours at ISO 6400), so it is possible that at this specific ISO setting the Canon does produce somewhat cleaner video (and slightly softer, due to more aggressive noise reduction). It is also possible that the person who shot this video has accidentally switched between the D5200’s footage and T4i’s. I should add that your T4i footage at ISO 6400 is similar to the footage produced by my T4i at the same ISO value.

    Again, thank you very much — keep up the excellent work.

    • Hello Marietta,

      I was most convinced of the softness of the lens when I used live view and maginifed for manual focus. Some text I was focused on was just very soft at high magnification and I wasn’t seeing that on the Canon side. I tried another kit lens and it was better but still not great. I then switched to the 40mm f/2.8 prime and it worked quite well. So in my case at least I do believe it was the lens. I will be taking more photos though but your links are worth a read.

      Regarding the low light tests – I too was surprised at the results. There are quite a few variables and I am not sure if any impact video but I was careful to keep all extra settings off. I would like to shoot more at 800, 1600 and 3200 in lower light and see what I get.

      Thanks,
      toby

Leave a Reply

five × three =