Photo Mish Mash 42: CES & Montana
/In all the editing many of you missed the question of the week (from the podcast) - I have it queued up for ya. Leave a comment on the video with your answer.[embed]http://youtu.be/OpsH_L8k5qs[/embed]
In all the editing many of you missed the question of the week (from the podcast) - I have it queued up for ya. Leave a comment on the video with your answer.[embed]http://youtu.be/OpsH_L8k5qs[/embed]
Question of the week -If you were going to make a coffee table photo book - what would be the subject?Week/month in review:Family Vacation (shooting experience with the GH4 and qualty of the high ISO filesISO 2500 examples https://www.dropbox.com/s/852e2tgii623064/Screenshot%202015-01-13%2008.28.42.png?dl=0https://www.dropbox.com/s/ketgoe9tjac85ar/Screenshot%202015-01-13%2008.31.54.png?dl=02x Extender Review: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=uIIp1F9bkTYDepth Of field Master Link: http://www.dofmaster.com/dofjs.htmlB&H Tour - Microphone room, Speaker Room and Zoom LensNew Style of the Photo Critique:Week Ahead -Montana - http://mckaylive.com/bozeman-animals-wyellowstone-15-spots-left-january-16-21-2015/Annoucements!http://www.patreon.com/photorectobyWorkshopsSignup for newsletterNews:CES - Photo round up http://gadgets.ndtv.com/cameras/features/ces-2015-cameras-roundup-646806Nikon D5500 (feb 5th) http://digital.photorecommendations.com/recs/2015/01/nikon-d5500-announced-successor-to-the-d5300/Canon P&S (Connect Station) - Glimpse of a new rebel?http://www.canonrumors.com/2015/01/a-new-xxd-dslr-coming-from-canon-cr1/New 18-300 IS STM Ef-S coming. . maybeCP+ Feb 12-15th - Maybe 5D Mark IV, T6i, D7200http://www.cpplus.jp/en/aim/Christina’s favorite camera - the HTC RE http://www.androidauthority.com/htcs-re-live-stream-youtube-579249/http://petapixel.com/assets/uploads/2015/01/rankings.jpghttps://www.flickr.com/camerashttp://spaceref.com/nasa-hack-space/large-synoptic-survey-telescope-camera-receives-funding-approval.htmlDiscussion:Roger Hunt / Tony LawrenceCalculating depth of field . . . should you base it on the focal length of the lens or the lens + crop factor . . . also suggested by someone else on Post to Your Page was how to use the depth of field button on the cameraReader Questions:Scott RobelotCan you please explain the best way to clean the mirror inside of a dslr?relayer705I have a Q. Will a 24 mp sensor be better in low light than a 16 mp? I have a Nikon D5100. I know that a full frame is much better in low light but would more mp make any difference in smaller sensor?Gerald MeredithAny experience with 5D Mark 3 underexposing in "manual mode" even if viewfinder meter shows correct exposure? All other modes seem okMiguel Rocha5D mk2 or 6D?
Canon hasn't announced any new DSLRs at CES 2015 (Nikon did Announced the D5500) but they did announce a slew of new P&S cameras and an interesting base station/external disk/NAS.
The Connect Station CS100, available in April for $299, is designed as an all-purpose destination for all the files on your camera, touch an NFC enabled camera to the station and via wifi your images are loaded onto the 1TB drive. The station allows connecting to computers, smartphones and tablets over the web while storing everything locally. Your own personal cloud that lives in the house. I am personally curious to see if the NFC and Wifi tech is included in the next Rebel (the T6i) and how well this will work with Lightroom.Where is the Canon T6i announcement? Probably in Early February.Canon P&S Cameras announced (all compatible with the Connect Station CS100)The PowerShot SX710 HS $349 | Pre-order from B&H PhotoHeadline Feature: Slight update to the excellent all around travel camera - Good sensor, plenty of zoom, Wifi and still pocketable.
Canon PowerShot SX 610HS $249| Pre-order from B&H PhotoHeadline Feature: Splits the difference between zoom and pocketable, Wifi too.
Canon PowerShot SX 530HS $429| Pre-order from B&H PhotoHeadline Feature- 50X ZOOM with Framing Assist (easier to see and focus on distant objects as you zoom)
Canon PowerShot ELPH 170 IS $149| Pre-order from B&H PhotoHeadline feature: 12x zoom in a slim form factor.
Canon PowerShot ELPH 160 $119| Pre-order from B&H PhotoHeadline Feature: CHEAP :)
The Nikon D5500 has been announced. (Why not a D5400?)Nikon D5500 camera, Nikkor 300 f/4 and 55-200mm f/4-5.6G lenses
Headline Feature: Articulating Touch Screen ( a first for the Nikon DSLR line)Additional Features:
About the touchscreen - "One of eight frequently used camera settings (Focus-point selection, AF-area mode, Aperture, ISO sensitivity, etc.) can be assigned to this function for use with viewfinder shooting, enabling immediate modification of the assigned setting, and achieving practical operation by simply tapping or sliding a finger across the monitor while looking through the viewfinder.""..sliding a finger across the monitor while looking through the viewfinder."Very interesting - I am curious to see how this translates in real world use.The Nikon D5500 will be available in early February, (black and red), in two different kit configurations: alongside the AF-S DX NIKKOR 18-55mm f/3.5-5.6G VR II lens for a suggested retail price (SRP) of $999.95 or with the AF-S DX NIKKOR 18-140mm f/3.5-5.6G ED VR lens for $1,199.95 SRP. The Nikon D5500 will also be sold body only for an SRP of $899.95. The AF-S DX NIKKOR 55-200mm f/4.5-5.6G ED VR II and AF-S NIKKOR 300mm f/4E PF ED VR lenses will also be available in early February for an SRP of $349.95 and $1,999.95, respectively.Preorder from Amazon | B&H Photo & Video (Available Feb 5th in RED or BLACK)B&H D5500 body only $896.95B&H D5500 with 18-55 $996.96B&H D5500 with 18-140 $1196.95
It looks like both share the same sensor, same processor and same number/type of focus points. In short do NOT upgrade to this camera from the D5300 and expect any difference in quality of the images.Key differences. D5500 offers a touchscreen, better battery life 820 vs 600 shots and its just a tiny bit smaller/lighter (just 2oz less than the D5300) - Some don't consider a smaller size to be better.From the Nikon Rumors Page - blue outline is the D5500, purple is the D5300
They have dropped the GPS (which I wasn't impressed with) but added some additional picture controls and maybe a star trails mode (I am still researching this)
Full post coming soon - for now watch my video of the T5i vs the D5300 and keep in mind the touchscreen should make the D5500 more user friendlyWhen will we see a Canon response to the D5500? When will we see the Canon T6i or 750D? I predict before the end of February
Available Feb 5th for $396 - Preorder from B&H PhotoPoll - How do you feel about touchscreens in your DSLR?

Upload Files through dbinbox.com
There is a current assignment "Shadow Play" that will be Critiqued the last week of February - Submit below by the end of the day February 23rd. Same rules apply except image should represent the idea of "Shadow Play".Upload Files through dbinbox.comFebruary Assignment - "Shadow Play"March & April Assignments - Submit ideas now :)
This has been rumored for months and now confirmed with a recent Interview. Photorumors has the complete details of the interview with a Canon Exec. The auto translation from Japanese to English is rough but a fluent reader on DPreview has summarized nicely. Highlights of the interview:
They say the best presents in life are free- This use of dropbox is certainly an awesome present that won't cost you anything and will bring your relatives (especially the parents and grandparents) joy throughout year. It involves setting up two dropbox accounts, one for you and one for the relative and setting the desktop wallpaper or screensaver to pull images from a folder inside your dropbox that you have shared with the relative. This allows you to drop images into this folder at anytime that will automatically show in their screensaver or as desktop wallpaper. You need:A dropbox account for you (free - sign up here)A dropbox account for a relative/friend (free)Access to the relatives computer (visiting for the holidays?)A pile of images - You should size these about 2400 pixels longSteps:




Do you have a favorite Dropbox use or hack? Love to hear it - share in the comments here or on my facebook page: https://www.facebook.com/Digital.Photo.Recommendations Bonus - You can even use the folder for your android wallpaper via the App Muzei and Dropzei. I don't know of a iOS option, if you do feel free to share in the comments or on my Facebook page https://www.facebook.com/Digital.Photo.Recommendations
Photo Mish Mash Ep #45 Date: 12/19/14Question: Photo Resolutions for 2015?Week in review:D750 Review -Touchscreen DebateCold Weather - touchscreen glovesHOT PINKCheap 50mmThe last image critique of 2014Film vs Digital CostsYear in review:What camera did we shoot with most?What focal length?http://regex.info/blog/lightroom-goodiesNews:Flickr is Sorry :(http://blog.flickr.net/en/2014/12/18/an-update-on-flickr-wall-art/https://www.lenstag.com/?Photography is the successor to the great art of the past (QUote by?)And Peter Lik’s 6.5 million print - something more expensivehttp://www.jeff-frost.com/modernruin/h1438b88d#h1438b88dJeff Frosts - http://vimeo.com/channels/staffpicks/106181453Instagram is now worth 35 Billion and surpassed Twitter in users. . . .http://www.dpreview.com/articles/6769417344/fujifilm-announces-macro-tubes-x-t1-firmware-availability-and-x-series-firmware-updateshttp://www.dpreview.com/articles/0350654437/bpg-image-format-aims-to-replace-jpegsAdobe has bought Fotolia and will be rolling it into their Creative Cloud subscriptionDiscussion:Higher ISOSSony A7s vs GH4Savings, Convenience (size, weight, lenses battery life, 4k crop and FUN!)If I was shooting weddings or needed to be ready for anything anytime - a7S would probably be my pick but for my needs GH4 is sweet.B&H DealReader Questions:printing your own photos on Pixma pro 100 or other printers, battery grips primary manufacture or third partyTheBiscuitHDDo you think that the canon 24-70mm f/4 is a good option for filmmaking ?Wesley OxenhamIs there a cheap canon prime lens (non-L-lens) that is better than an expensive zoom L lens? (comparing the same focal length)Dalibor MrkicAre we going to see assignment critique again?Todd Davisis there any reason to keep old images on your HD from clients that have already paid? How would putting them on DVD etc, work?Frank WhiteQuestion: Do you and Christina plan to get into hybrid photography (marrying photography with vidoeography)?OldSchoolandNewAny thoughts on printing your own photos rather than sending to a lab...maybe on a canon Pixma pro 100?Knut Aage Dahlwould IS be a valuable feature when you grab stills from a video?Matt JuneWill you ever have a local meetup? I mean like a greet and meet?good general posing book.. suggestions?Creative Live Classes -https://www.facebook.com/Digital.Photo.Recommendations/photos/a.10150222907829855.334190.233048999854/10152943043379855/?type=1Good Flash for E5 - http://www.amazon.com/dp/B003LWH156/?tag=yt_dpr-20Recommended Books -Understanding Exposure by Bryan Peterson http://www.amazon.com/dp/0817439390/?tag=yt_dpr-20Your best shot of 2014
Submit your favorite photo taken in 2014 to be displayed at the end of our last podcast of the year (Live starting at 7pm EST on 12/19/14)
Yongnuo, the company that makes some of my favorite flashes for Canon and Nikon, has recently released their own version of Canon's 50mm f/1.8. Costing just $30, less than a 1/3 the price of Canon's already cheap 50mm intrigued reader John Witkowski. Here are his thoughts and some comparisons versus the Canon 40mm f/2.8. YONGNUO 50mm f/1.8 lens for Canon cameras. Initial thoughts so far; it seems to be built just a tad bit better than canons 50mm 1.8, not by much. Mount uses screws instead of canons plastic lock tabs. Quick test shots seem to have accurate color and contrast. Not as sharp as the 40mm 2.8 it is very soft at 1.8 and gets better around f4 - f5. Ok bokeh. Motor noise is similar to the canon 50 1.8. Focusing is ok not to bad to get locked in. With that said It does not work in liveview with my t5i. It has trouble focusing and when it finally does come in focus the camera will not shoot. I noticed if it is in live view with the lens on AF it will not fire. If I change the lens to MF in live view it works. Using the viewfinder the lens works fine. So far for $30 bucks its not bad but not great. See John's Flickr Photos at https://www.flickr.com/photos/limesaresweet/sets/72157649727835016
Canon 40mm f/2.8 at f/2.8https://www.flickr.com/photos/limesaresweet/15414584774/in/set-72157649727835016Yongnuo 50mm f/1.8 at f/1.8https://www.flickr.com/photos/limesaresweet/16036156502/in/set-72157649727835016/Yongnuo 50mm f/1.8 at f/2.8https://www.flickr.com/photos/limesaresweet/15849416238/in/set-72157649727835016/100% comp 40mm f/2.8 @ f/2.8 vs Yongnuo 50mm f/1.8 @ f/2.8
More samples on his Flickr Page -https://www.flickr.com/photos/limesaresweet/sets/72157649727835016You can order the lens via Ebay (price seems to have gone up slightly) Yongnuo 50mm f/1.8 Canon Lens or Amazon (price is higher) My quick thoughts - at $30-$40 if offers a workable alternative to Canon's own prime but you are probably better off saving a little more and grabbing the Canon version, especially when you consider the focusing issues John mentioned along with the serious softness at f/1.8. Let me know your thoughts in the comments.
One of my viewers shared his thoughts on film vs digital and did a nice cost benefit analysis. I asked if I could share it as a post and he agreed. Thanks to Norbert from Belgium for sharing. I'd like to talk to you a little about (spoiler alert )...old-fashioned analog photography. One and a half years back I became seriously interested in photography after my purchase of my first DSLR (Rebel T3 with the 17-50 f/2.8 Tamron. I rather wanted the fixed aperture instead of a more expensive body with a flippy touchscreen) and purchased my first prime lens last spring (the new Sigma 30mm f/1.4). Since then I've spend a good $1300,- worth of camera equipment. That amount of money is a lot for a just graduated vet with photography as (just) a hobby. After being inspired last summer by a friend owning a Canon AE-1 Program, I began calculating the cost of analog photography. I did a little search on eBay and estimated that with a budget of around $130,-, I could buy myself a professional level SLR. I made a little Excel sheet to calculate the price per photo if I would bring the film rolls to a local lab to get it developed and scanned on a CD (that way I avoid printing costs).View the spreadsheet in own windowI came to a price of $0,32 cents per photo (Calculated the prices roughly to dollars, but maybe real American prices differ a bit). Eventually I bought an Olympus OM-2 (because of it's compact size and huge viewfinder) with a 50mm f/1.8, 35mm f/2.8, a little flash and batteries for both the camera and the little flash for a total of $120,-. So far, I'm really happy with it for four reasons:
You have to think about your exposure settings and the photos you take. On a DSLR you can cheat. Great, but it doesn't learn you much. A SLR pushes you to 'read' the light and to be fully in charge of the composition of a photo (and not waste a few shots to check your composition afterwards). You really have to "think before you click" .Returning to the financial side of things, I wanted to compare my digital versus my analog equipment. I had a bias towards digital (like most people probably) that digital has the big advantage that you can shoot for free. I calculated that I would have to shoot 70 rolls of film before the costs of my analog equipment would equal the costs of my digital equipment. Assuming that I shoot four 36-rolls a month (one per week), that would take me 2.25 years. I think for the average amateur photographer, that's not much shorter than the period after people tend to upgrade their gear. Additionally, upgrading your analog equipment, by for example buying that extra lens, is also much cheaper and with the difference in money you can buy some film again.Editors Note: Here in the US MPIX.COM will develop negatives for 0.19/exposure extending the time to 2.56 years.And yes, there are drawbacks to analog photography of course. Mainly two big ones, I feel.
Of course, analog photography would be impossible harder for the modern professional photographer. But I think it's a good 'instrument' for the amateur level photographer, I thought it might be a good idea to share this idea with you. Analog photography is often regarded as a bit romantic and hipster (think Lomography). I would like to point out that analog photograph can also be a good alternative for the rationally thinking amateur photographer.I added two of my favorite images from my last film roll .
All the best from Ghent, Belgium,Norbert
I have been shooting with the Nikon D750 for the last month and it is time to share my thoughts with you.https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=oOC7D6U-Xp4
D610 Offers an excellent sensor for just $1500D750 Offers a versatile camera that excels in low light focusing and produces very clean images at high ISOsD810 offers 36MP with no optical low pass filter (OLPF) this gives you stunningly detailed images
D610 and the D750 share partial MA Skeleton. D750 gets carbon fiber exterior increasing strength and decreasing weightNikon Full Frame DSLR Weight:
One of the headline features of the D750 is the articulating display. The first full frame DSLR to offer. There is some nervousness surrounding the ribbon connection powe to the screen and yes an articulating screen is more prone to issues but all in all the additional angles you can shoot at without craning your neck or guesstimating on the composition are appreciated. The D750 is the smallest of the three and like the D610 some buttons on the left have dual purposes depending on the mode you are in. I find this to be slightly annoying The D810 has a dedicated button for almost everything and includes a dedicated AF-ON button too.
The D750 has the newest focusing system of the three cameras with excellent performance in low light. Same points and spread as the D810 but with better low light performance. D610 is capable but not my first pick for speedy focusing when the light levels drop.
My Favorite features of the Nikon D750
A few small items that I don't love about the D750.
Overall I would be very happy to use this camera professionally.
Starting to hear some rumors about the D5400 which according to this post on Nikon Rumors will be called the D5500. Skipping the D5400. It seems the number 4 in Japanese has the same pronunciation as the word for "death" (shi) and thus they avoid it. (Thanks Tom C.) Why their flagship DSLR is named the D4s causes me some confusion but let's set the number/name aside and talk about the features.At this point we know very little other than a touchscreen will be added to the articulating screen and the camera will be announced in early January in time for Consumer Electronics Show (CES). I suspect most other features will remain the same or similar with the D5300 and expect Nikon to use the same excellent 24mp sensor that they are currently using.I hear from many photographers upgrading to DSLRS that feel torn between the increased quality of the Nikon but want the touchscreen of the Canon T5i. This should help with the decision but I expect (or hope) Canon will come back with something in the T6i that gives them a fighting chance. Right now Canon does have a clear advantage with the dual pixel AF and the STM lenses if you want to easily capture video but on the photo side Nikon is my pick. Early rumors that I reported on suggested Canon would go mirror-less for the T6i but I doubt that is true, what will be more likely is the inclusion of the 70Ds fast live view focusing system.How do you feel about touchscreens in your DSLR? Do you have one and love it? Don't have one and don't think you would want it? Christina and I touch on the touchscreen debate and talk about the D5500 in this segment from our weekly podcast.Poll - How do you feel about touchscreens in your DSLR?
Updates on my review of the Nikon D750, Is photography Art? A recent 6.5 Million dollar photo stirs some controversy, The D5500 is rumored, skipping the D5400 - you might be surprised to find out why. Lytro cameras now offer focus spread and we answer reader AND viewer questions. This was our first live show and a big thanks to all those that jumped in and commented/shared their thoughts as we recorded. More live shows are in the future.News:Lytro offers Focus Spread Technology http://www.popphoto.com/gear/2014/12/lytro-focus-spread-technology-gives-you-full-control-over-depth-field-after-fact?dom=tw&src=SOCNikon D5500 Rumours will include a touchscreenDiscussion:Is Photography ART? This recurring discussion was brought to the forefront again when Peter Liks "Phantom" sold for $6.5 million and Jonathan Jones of the Guardian had strong opinions that photography is not ART.http://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/jonathanjonesblog/2014/dec/10/most-expensive-photograph-ever-hackneyed-tastelessThe photo in color: http://www.lik.com/thework/canyons-arches/ghost.htmlFor reference Google Search results of Antelope Canyon http://luvit.me/1Au79cmReaderQuestionsQuestion-- body or lens?? What is more important to the overall AF experience?Do you know how much the 5DMk4 will cost?Should I wait to buy the Canon 5D III? Is canon going to refresh the line-up?Would there be an increase in image quality and low light performance going from an XSi to a 7D mk1?5D MK IV with Sony or Canon sensor?More towards the business end, for people in portrait photography, what are the best ways to get your name out there other than word of mouth and FB utilization.I have a crop sensor dslr(70D). For christmas, I have the budget for either, a canon L lens like 24-70mm or a full frame body. What do you recommend I buy?Are all macro lenses change their max aperture when you focus closer to the subject?
We talk about the best selling cameras on Cyber Monday, properly show you all the goodies in the next giveaway, talk about the 7D Mark II sensor, let slip that we are not big sports fans and share our holiday gift list.Photo Mish Mash Ep #39 Date: 12/5/14Sponsor(s): Greece Trip Join us in Greece: http://mckaylive.com/greece-2015/2:40 Week in review:Most popular items sold on Cyber Monday at B&H Photo VideoFF DSLR List: http://bhpho.to/1rVN2osAPS-C DSLR List: http://bhpho.to/1pZYhLbMirrorless: http://bhpho.to/1ylunUFRugged Compact: http://bhpho.to/1ySND9FAction Cameras: http://bhpho.to/1232in5Sigma 18-300 Review and Vs Tamron: http://youtu.be/ykWP-Gv9yA8Tenba Bag: http://youtu.be/0McCXOzTxDwGiveaway!!! http://bit.ly/DPR14giveaway2Tenba bagBenro TripodBlack Rapid CurveFP GearMishMash Roots:Tao Tronics Lamp - http://geni.us/TaoTronicsLampWeek ahead:2nd Opinion the Fuji Xt-131:20 News:ClarkVision- Mathematical Formula on upgrading and Review of Canon 7D Mark II http://www.clarkvision.com/articles/exposure.and.upgrades/index.html7D Mark II studio samples - mirroring what I have seen. http://bit.ly/1vmx7djCanon getting serious in 2015 with a full frame mirrorless camera http://www.canonwatch.com/canon-going-serious-mirrorless-2015-full-frame-milc-coming/Selfie cam with a weird namehttp://www.engadget.com/2014/12/04/casio-exilim-mr1-selfie-camera/Top ten instagrammed locations of 2014http://petapixel.com/2014/12/03/count-top-10-instagrammed-locations-2014/51:16 Discussion:Holiday Gift ListToby's Guide: http://digital.photorecommendations.com/recs/2014/11/holiday-gift-guide-2014/Christina's Guide: http://digital.photorecommendations.com/recs/2014/11/christinas-gift-guide-2014/1:04:00 Reader Questionshttps://www.facebook.com/Digital.Photo.Recommendations/photos/a.10150222907829855.334190.233048999854/10152910704544855/?type=1
These two APS-C lenses give you an equivalent range of 28mm to 480mm!! A huge range and this I am calling this
| Feature | Tamron 18–300mm f/3.5–6.3 Di III-A VC VXD | Sigma 18–300mm f/3.5–6.3 DC DN OS Contemporary | Comments |
|---|---|---|---|
| Mounts Available | Sony E (APS-C), Fujifilm X | Sony E (APS-C), L-Mount (coming soon) | Both are designed for modern mirrorless systems. |
| Zoom Range (Full-Frame Eqv.) | 27 – 450 mm (16.6× zoom) | 27 – 450 mm (16.6× zoom) | Identical coverage from wide to telephoto. |
| Aperture Range | f/3.5 – 6.3 | f/3.5 – 6.3 | Same maximum aperture on both lenses. |
| Autofocus System | VXD (Voice-coil eXtreme-torque Drive) linear motor | Stepper motor AF | Tamron’s AF is faster and quieter, especially for tracking. |
| Image Stabilization | VC (Vibration Compensation) | OS (Optical Stabilizer) | Both are effective; Tamron’s VC works slightly better for video. |
| Minimum Focus Distance / Macro | 0.15 m (5.9 in) / 1:2 magnification | 0.39 m (15.4 in) / 1:3 magnification | Tamron wins for close-up and macro versatility. |
| Build Quality / Weather Sealing | Moisture-resistant with fluorine coating | Basic dust and splash resistance | Tamron feels more refined and durable. |
| Weight / Size | 620 g (21.9 oz) / 125.8 mm length | 615 g (21.7 oz) / 122 mm length | Nearly identical; both compact for their range. |
| Price (October 2025) | ≈ $699 new (often on sale ~ $559) | ≈ $799 new | Tamron typically runs $100–$200 less. |
| Overall Performance | Excellent sharpness, fast AF, great macro ability | Good sharpness, slower AF, less macro reach | Tamron offers a more complete package for travel and hybrid shooters. |
Summary: Both lenses deliver an impressive all-in-one zoom range for APS-C mirrorless shooters, but the Tamron 18–300mm f/3.5–6.3 Di III-A VC VXD stands out for its faster autofocus, stronger macro performance, better weather sealing, and lower price. The Sigma remains a solid choice, but the Tamron feels like the more polished and travel-ready option overall.
OLDER - DSLR LENS REVIEW BELOW
I am generally not a fan of do-it-all lenses. Lenses that cover this much range make sacrifices in quality—sharpness, distortion, chromatic aberration. But when I reviewed the newer Tamron 16-300 a few months ago, I was pleasantly surprised by its performance. Yes, it still has issues, but it held up quite well. And I certainly enjoy the convenience—especially when traveling or hiking—of carrying just one lens that provides a huge range, decent macro capabilities, and image stabilization for handheld video.
Then Sigma released an 18-300, and I have been asked repeatedly to compare these two lenses.
Bottom Line on These Lenses
These lenses are for someone who is happy with the quality of the kit lens that came with their camera but wants more zoom without having to switch lenses.
These lenses are not for someone who frequently shoots in low light or wants the absolute sharpest image quality.
Personally, I suggest carrying one of these do-it-all lenses along with a small prime like a 24mm or 35mm. It’s a compromise on the carry-only-one-lens philosophy, but it gives you an excellent low-light, sharp lens option when you really need it—without adding much bulk or weight to your camera bag.
Now, Which of These Two Lenses Is Better?
I’ll give you the answer up front: 9 out of 10 times, I would pick the Tamron over the Sigma, despite the Sigma being marginally sharper at some focal lengths.
Why? The Tamron has faster focusing, full-time manual focus, weather sealing, a nicer focus indicator, and starts just a little wider.
Build Quality & Features – Both lenses have similar construction, made of tough plastic. From a distance, you might mistake the Sigma for metal, but it’s the same basic material as the Tamron. Both feel well made, feature telescoping zoom, and have internal focusing—great for using circular polarizers.
• Filter Size: Tamron uses 67mm; Sigma uses 72mm.
• Lens Hood: Both include one.
One downside of the Tamron is its small and slippery AF/MF and IS (VC) switches. Sigma’s switches are slightly taller and easier to operate. However, the Tamron offers full-time manual focus, a great feature that allows quick fine-tuning. On a lens with this much range, focusing can be slow, and the ability to assist AF or manually fine-tune focus makes for a much smoother experience.
The Tamron’s stabilization also seems slightly better—noticeable in slower shutter speed handholding and when shooting video, where it appears just a bit smoother.
Weight – Sigma: 1lb 5oz, Tamron: 1lb 4oz.
Focusing Speed – Both use ultrasonic focusing systems (HSM for Sigma, PZD for Tamron). I tested them at Longwood Gardens using a Canon 7D Mark II on a moving train display. In both One Shot and AI Servo modes, the Tamron consistently kept focus on trains moving directly toward me. With the Sigma, some shots were slightly out of focus—it was just a bit slower. The Tamron also performed slightly smoother in video focusing.
Macro Capabilities – Identical for both lenses.
• Close Focus Distance: 15” with AF, ~6” with MF.
• Magnification: Same for both.
• Sigma’s 2x Magnification Filter: A $50 screw-on filter designed to double magnification.
Image Quality
• Sharpness: The Sigma is slightly sharper, and when viewing at 100% or more, the difference is noticeable.
• Chromatic Aberration: The Sigma shows significantly more purple/magenta fringing, which may be due to its increased sharpness.
Roger Clark at ClarkVision (http://www.clarkvision.com/) has completed his review of the 7D Mark II and found the sensor to be the BEST low light Canon sensor on the market.A few lines from his conclusion-
The data shown here for the Canon 7D Mark II indicate that the camera is operating at near perfect levels for the sensor with lower apparent read noise and impressively low pattern noise compared to all other current Canon cameras tested and better than that in the 7D Mark I. This means that for high signals, noise is dominated by photon statistics. Sensitivity is improved 14% over the 7D Mark 1, and the sensitivity per square micron is the highest that I have measured for any Canon camera to date.The approximately 10x lower thermal dark current is a game changing factor, making this camera the top Canon camera for long exposure low light photography that I have tested. The superb autofocus system, comparable to Canon 1D series pro cameras with 65 autofocus points is another game changing innovation, as the camera is at a price point that is affordable to more people.
Read his full and extremely detailed review at http://www.clarkvision.com/reviews/evaluation-canon-7dii/ This certainly inspires me to head out and take some long exposure shots - something I have not done with the 7D Mark II at this time. I can say the 7D Mark II is one of the nicest cameras I have held in hand - feels perfect and button layout and customization are wonderful.Buy your 7D Mark II from Amazon or B&H Photo Video (body only $1799)
Don’t forget you can tweet each day to increase your chances of winning!
The package you will winTenba Discovery Photo/Tablet Daypack Mini (my review) (Tenba Website)Benro USA - Aero 2 Angel Travel Video Tripod (my review) (Benro Website)Fusion Photo Gear Arca Swiss Style Fusion Plate (Fusion Website)Black Rapid Cross Strap (my review) (Black Rapid Website)
This is a list of suggested accessories, ideas and services. If you are looking for cameras see my recommended cameras/gear as of November 2014. If you want to see all current deals and Black Friday Deals on cameras and accessories.My Holiday Gift Guide - Compiled with the help of Roy McKee - Here is Roy's complete list of suggested gear and accessories. Christina has her own guide this year.
Lenses - Prime and Macro |
|
![]() |
A prime lens - If you don't have one you need one. I have 6 reasons you should get a prime lens this holiday season. If you are a Canon shooter I suggest the Canon 24mm (more here) in short it is a lovely focal length on your APS-C sensor Canons providing excellent quality and low light performance in a tiny package. Want a different focal length, maybe one better for portraits? I have a Canon Prime Lens Guide. The EFS 24mm is just $149 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Nikon Photographers I suggest you start with the 35mm f/1.8 as your first prime. A lovely focal length on a crop sensor camera, small, lightweight but provides excellent quality and very good low light capabilities with that f/1.8 maximum aperture. Just $196. Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Feeling stuck in a photographic rut or maybe you feel like the area you live isn't particularly photogenic - a macro lens is a nice escape- turn the hum drum world around you into something amazing. Macro lenses start affordable and quickly climb from there. For the cheapest option see the extension tubes I recommend next but for a dedicated lens Canon photographers can pick up the Canon EFS 60mm f/2.8 for just over $400 (with rebates). Buy from Amazon or B&H PHoto Video.Nikon Photographers can start with the 40mm DX lens for $275. Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video.Want something more serious? The Canon 100mm F/2.8 L IS is fantastic. With current rebates it is selling from $899. Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo VideoNikon photographers pick up the 90mm Tamron VC for $749 - Offering 4 stops of VC and excellent sharpness. Buy from Amazon or B&H PHoto VideoAs discussed in my macro video - many lenses are marked or sold as Macros but the only a true macro can reach 1:1 magnification and the ones I list above are true macros. |
![]() |
Macro Extension tubes - Earlier this year I released a longer video detailing several of your macro photography options including extension tubes. This set is an affordable way to get started with Macro photography using your existing lenses. Watch my video on Macro Options. Buy the Extension Tubes from B&H Photo Video (Nikon and Canon mounts available) | Amazon |
Tripods |
|
![]() |
LITTLE - Joby Tripod for GoPros and other small cameras (I successfully used mine with a Sony a5100) The feet have strong magnets making this tiny tripod much larger if you have something metal to stick it on. Railings, lampposts, cars all make good surfaces. $12.99 Buy from Amazon Buy from B&H Photo video for $10.99. |
![]() |
A tripod is extremely useful and the Dolica is an affordable entry level tripod that offers pro level features - I have a review and side by side comparison with the MeFoto below. $48.95 Buy from Amazon |
![]() |
MeFoto Travel Tripod - There are taller tripods, smaller tripods, lighter tripods but for me the MeFoto Travel Tripod and it's slight bigger brother the RoadTrip($189) hit the sweet spot of price, portability and performance. My Travel Tripod has always been tall enough for me and more importantly fits in my camera bag and consequently is with me when needed - one of the most important features of a tripod. $139.00 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video. |
![]() |
You have a tripod - Now give yourself an additional reason to use it and pick up the Triggertrap mobile dongle system- This little connector and cord allows you to turn your smartphone into a computer capable of triggering your camera in a variety of ways. I have a recent review of Triggertrap here. $24-34.Buy direct from Triggertrap |
Simple little gifts to make life easier / cleaner |
|
![]() |
Carson Cleaning cloth - Clean lenses, LCD Screens with this soft pouch handy cleaning cloth. $5.92 Buy from Amazon |
![]() |
Giottos cleaning solution - If you can't clean it with the cloth add a little of this solution. $5.99 Buy from Amazon |
![]() |
Giottos rocket - Blow the dust away. $8.95 Buy from Amazon |
Upgrade your strap |
|
![]() |
I love Black Rapid straps- A really nice alternative to the standard strap that always seems to be in my way and causing the camera to bounce around uncomfortably. Lots more about Black Rapids here and Roy's post on DYI to use the straps with a Manfrotto Tripod plate. $40 - $75 Buy on Amazon |
![]() |
Need to carry two cameras at the same time or one camera and a lens pouch? The Holdfast system will do it and you will look sharp too. $200 and up. Buy direct from Holdfast. or B&H Photo Video |
Splurge |
|
![]() |
DJI has released a new drone, just in time for the Holidays and I want one! Ready to fly out of the box - these things are amazingly stable, smart(I love watching the copters hold position or come in for a landing on their own) and offer some awesome opportunities for aerial footage. $2,899 Buy from B&H |
![]() |
5K imac - Want to speed through photo and video editing? I do and the newest imac offering a gorgeous display is one of the fastest computers you can plop on your desk today, the fact that it comes with a gorgeous 5k display makes it extra sweet. Base models start at $2,399. Buy from B&H |
![]() |
For video work or time lapse photography a slider can take ho-hum footage- I am eagerly waiting for my Nebo motion slider that you can preoder. If you are in a hurry pick up the Cinetics Axis360 Pro Motorized Motion Control System and Slider. Buy from B&H |
Home/Mobile Office |
|
![]() |
TaoTronic Lamp - It is important to have consistent lighting in your workspace and the TT-DL01 LED Desk Lamp provides good clean light with multiple brightness and temperature settings. USB Charging port is an added bonus. $52 Buy from Amazon |
![]() |
Cocoon GRID-IT! Organizer Case - Keep all those little bits and extra wires organized. $7 - $15. Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video. |
![]() |
Think Tank SD Pixel Pocket Rocket, Holds 9 SD Memory Cards - Keep those little cards full of your precious memories safe and organized. $16.75 Buy from Amazon or B&H PHoto Video |
![]() |
A good camera bag - ThinkTank makes a variety of styles and models and although they aren't cheap they are some of the best on the planet and they last. Treat yourself and treat your gear. Buy direct from ThinkTank |
Just Fun |
|
![]() |
I stuck the Fujifilm Instax Share Smartphone Portable Printer SP-1 in the just fun section but it can be quite a serious little addition to your camera bag, providing you with a way to immediately print photos and share something tangible with friends. $177.99 Buy from Amazon Buy from B&H Photo Video. |
![]() |
Bokeh Kit - Honestly you could make this on your own but the set is affordable and gives you a wide range of options. $24.95 Buy from Amazon |
![]() |
If you are the type of person that loves to apply a ton of filters to your images you might love the Holga lenses for your camera, available in Nikon or Canon mounts you slap this puppy on your camera and suddenly turn your expensive DSLR into an ancient crappy camera that can be lots of fun to use :) $24.95 Additional Filters available Canon - http://www.amzn.com/B0050C1A3E/?tag=dprroy-20 Nikon - http://www.amzn.com/B0050C1A48/?tag=dprroy-20 |
![]() |
Thermo Lens Mug - These have been around for a few years, my mom gave me mine last year and everyone LOVES It - fun to prank people with too ;) Pretend to drop an expensive lens or pour coffee into an expensive lens or. . you get the idea. $12.99 Buy from Amazon |
![]() |
I was one of those people that wasn't sure I needed a GoPro and a year after buying one I can't believe the amount of use I have gotten out of mine. Bike rides, zip lines, paragliding, underwater at the salmon hatchery, skiing, timelapse along california coast, playing with kids in the pool and much more. The Hero 3+ Silver offers all the features I have used at a great price - Wifi, 60FPS at full 1080 and 12MP resolution that is so impressive for such a little camera. B&H is currently offering some freebies including a spare battery and 32GB MicroSD card. Grab one quick - limited quantities. Buy from B&H |
Gift Cards |
|
![]() |
Amazon Gift Card - All but one of the items on this guide can be purchased on Amazon. If you're not ready to commit to gifting any one of these things, why not just nudge them in the right direction with an Amazon gift card? Amazon is offering $25 towards a digital camera if you buy someone a $100 Gift Card. |
![]() |
BH Photo Video Gift Card - Almost all of the items on this guide can also be purchased at B&H. You'll also get brownie points for it being a photography-specific gift card from one of the biggest camera stores in the world. Seriously, you can find just about anything at that store. |
![]() |
Artifact Uprising Gift Card - Few things are more rewarding to a photographer than seeing their images in print. Artifact Uprising offers a range of really beautiful and simple products to help bring photos from the digital world into the tangible world easily. Better yet - why not make your loved ones a photo book from one of your adventures with them? That's a gift they'll love forever |
My Holiday Gift Guide - Compiled with the help of Roy McKee - Here is Roy's complete list of suggested gear and accessories. Christina has her own guide this year.
Christina is a professional wedding photographer and co-host on our weekly Photo Mish Mash podcast. You can see more of her work at http://christinabernales.com/ or Instagram/Christinabernales
![]() |
ONA Bag Insert - This insert is awesome for when I'm traveling light and I want to bring along my DSLR, a few extra accessories and my daily items. At $69 it's a very well-made, versatile accessory for the photographer in your life. Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
ONA Presidio Leather Camera Strap - This camera strap is stylish and the leather is long-lasting and it just gets more and more comfortable over time. ONA has canvas straps, too, but leather is a classic look that will look great through the decades. $99 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video. |
![]() |
HoldFast Dual Camera Strap in Bison Leather - Are you seeing a theme here? I really dig leather goods. Like the neck strap, this dual camera strap is the most comfortable (and stylish) way to carry two cameras at once for hours on end. The bison is ultra-soft but all the leathers soften overtime and mold to your body for the perfect fit. $300 - $310 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
ONA Brixton Messenger Camera Bag - This bag is beautiful functional, and like with all other ONA products, solidly built. I'd be elated to see this beautiful bag this holiday. $279 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video. |
![]() |
Lensbaby with Edge 80 Optic - This is a super fun way to get creative with those cool tilt-shift photos without breaking the bank. This is my favorite Lensbaby Optic of them all. $499. Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video. |
![]() |
Lensbaby Composer - Don't want to splurge on the Edge 80? This Lensbaby Composer kit is perfect for anyone looking to get started. You can always add the Edge 80 Optic on later. And don't forget Lensbaby makes these fun lenses for just about all camera mounts! $199.95 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video (Instant savings at B&H brings price down to $159.95 |
![]() |
Sigma Art 50mm F/1.4 Lens - This is probably my favorite lens ever. Its sharpness is unmatched and its price cannot be beat. They say it rivals Zeiss glass and it's true. It's the best. $949 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Sigma Art 35mm F1.4 Lens - Same as the fifty but a little wider. My second favorite lens. $899 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Fujifilm Instax 210 - Fuji makes several of these but the 210 landscape version is my favorite. This is a great gift for just about anyone - friends, siblings, cousins, nieces, nephews, or significant others. These Fuji cameras bring photography back to being the tangible piece of instant nostalgia that it was during the Polaroid era. $58.49 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Panasonic Lumix GH4 - This camera is a videographer's dream. It's silky smooth to focus and offers amazing video and photo quality at a very good price. I want it. Do you want it? Cause I want it. Recent price drop to $1497 (B&H includes a few freebies too) Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Fujifilm XT1 - The electronic viewfinder on this camera is as dreamy as the image quality. It looks like a vintage rangefinder without having to worry about developing any film. Definitely on my list. $1198 Buy from Amazon or B&H Photo Video |
![]() |
Canonet QL7 GIII - And for the analog photography lover in your life. Here's a super cool, affordable fun camera. ~$50 Buy on ebay |
![]() |
Amazon Gift Card - All but one of the items on this guide can be purchased on Amazon. If you're not ready to commit to gifting any one of these things, why not just nudge them in the right direction with an Amazon gift card? Amazon is offering $25 towards a digital camera if you buy someone a $100 Gift Card. |
![]() |
BH Photo Video Gift Card - Almost all of the items on this guide can also be purchased at B&H. You'll also get brownie points for it being a photography-specific gift card from one of the biggest camera stores in the world. Seriously, you can find just about anything at that store. |
![]() |
Artifact Uprising Gift Card - Few things are more rewarding to a photographer than seeing their images in print. Artifact Uprising offers a range of really beautiful and simple products to help bring photos from the digital world into the tangible world easily. Better yet - why not make your loved ones a photo book from one of your adventures with them? That's a gift they'll love forever |
See my Gift Guide for 2014